GC Solar 23.61 GW GD Solar 53.65 GW
Opinion Article

Non-incidence of ICMS on TUSD, TUST and sectoral charges

After all, is ICMS applicable on contracted demand, even when consumed?

The tariff structure of the electricity sector is complex

As already reported by Canal Solar, on June 23, 2022, was Complementary Law 194/2022 (LC 194/2022) published, which reduced the amount of ICMS due on operations with fuel, natural gas, electricity, communications and transport services.

Since then, a lot has happened, as all 26 States and the Federal District announced the reduction of ICMS, limiting the percentage to operations in general (17% or 18%), and which was immediately felt in consumers' pockets.

However, almost no State has commented on the new item X of article 3 of Complementary Law 87/1996 (Kandir Law), added by LC 194/2022, and which has been the subject of debate and a lot of insecurity in the electricity sector.

Said section states that ICMS does not apply to transmission and distribution services and sectoral charges linked to electricity operations. Simple writing, but with complexity and impact that is very relevant for the sector.

Just to give an example, some relevant questions have been asked by sector agents:

  • Is ICMS applicable on contracted demand, even when consumed?
  • Should sectoral charges applied to the Energy Tariff also be excluded from the ICMS calculation basis?
  • Regarding tariff flags, is ICMS applicable after LC 194/2022?

As the tariff structure of the electricity sector is complex, Working Group 13 (GT13) of COTEPE (Permanent Technical Commission of ICMS – COTEPE/ICMS), linked to CONFAZ, sent Official Letter SEI No. 202349/2022/ME to ANEEL, to clarify which tariff components should be excluded from the ICMS calculation base, with the advent of LC 194/2022, as well as whether it would be possible to do so, given the current tariff composition.

The answer to this letter can be checked here and to illustrate, it resulted in two tables as shown in PRORET, which for the ANEEL, should be excluded from the ICMS calculation base, as they are components that refer to the remuneration of transmission and distribution services and sector charges (in red).

In possession of this response, it is believed that GT 13 now has sufficient tools to decide and guide States on the interpretation to be given to section ICMS levied on electrical energy for consumers.

Einar Tribuci
About the Author
Einar Tribuci

Professor of the course Taxes on Consumption and Generation of Electrical Energy at Canal Solar. Graduated in Law from São Judas Tadeu University in São Paulo, and holds a specialization in Tax Law from the Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo. With a career spanning over 20 years, Tribuci has extensive experience in tax consulting and planning, working on tax reviews for medium and large-sized companies. He is the owner and partner of the law firm Tribuci Advogados.

Comments

Comments are moderated before publication.

Comments should be respectful and contribute to a healthy debate. Offensive comments may be removed. The opinions expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the author. Canal Solar.

Leave your comment

Canal Solar
Privacy

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognizing you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.